SCORING CRITERIA

Each film is graded 1 to 10 in the following categories:

 

1. Originality / Creativity

How unique, bold, and imaginative the project is.
Does it bring something new to horror or execute a familiar idea in a fresh way?

 

2. Direction

The filmmaker’s vision, tone control, and ability to create effective scenes.
Does the director guide the film with confidence and purpose?

 

3. Writing

Strength of story, characters, structure, dialogue, and thematic cohesion.
Does it deliver a compelling narrative or concept?

 

4. Cinematography

Shot composition, lighting, camera movement, and visual storytelling.
Is the imagery engaging and supportive of the tone?

 

5. Performances

Quality and believability of the actors.
Do the performances elevate the film or weaken the immersion?

 

6. Production Value

Practical effects, design, locations, costuming, and overall craftsmanship.
We judge effort and effectiveness, not budget.

 

7. Pacing

Flow, rhythm, and how well tension is built and maintained.
Does the film feel tight and intentional?

 

8. Structure

Narrative clarity, editing, consistency, and progression.
Does the film feel well-constructed from start to finish?

 

9. Sound / Music

Clarity, mixing, original score, sound design, and atmosphere.
Does sound enhance the experience or distract from it?

 

 

AVERAGE SCORE

All categories are averaged to determine the project's overall rating.
Scores help place projects, but judges also discuss standout elements that numbers alone cannot capture.

 

 

AWARD SELECTION PROCESS

Feature Films & Short Films

These categories automatically qualify for:

• Excellence in Score

• Excellence in Practical Effects

Judges evaluate these extra elements directly from the film’s performance in the main scoring categories.

 

Screenplays

Evaluated based on writing, originality, structure, concept, and emotional/atmospheric impact.

 

Trailers

Judged on pacing, tone, cohesion, sound, music, and their ability to create intrigue.

 

Horror Haven Award

Chosen directly by the Festival Director.
This award goes to the project that embodies the heart of Horror Haven:

• ambition

• originality

• passion

• independent spirit

​